Skip to content

Ocean life

US proposes opening Pacific marine reserve to fishing

New federal draft regulations would permit commercial fleets across one million square kilometers of ocean sheltering whales, turtles, and ancient coral reefs.

Reported by Mongabay · · 2 min read

On the map: United States · Corals · Whales · Turtles and tortoises

US proposes opening Pacific marine reserve to fishing
Image: Mongabay

United States federal authorities have released a regulatory draft aimed at allowing commercial fishing fleets into vast sections of a Pacific marine reserve. The territory under consideration spans approximately one million square kilometers, or 408,000 square miles, an expanse greater than twice the land area of California that includes atolls, seamounts, and ancient coral formations.

Published on November 9 by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration's fisheries division, the initiative seeks to remove existing harvest bans surrounding Wake Island, Johnston Atoll, and Jarvis Island within the Pacific Islands Heritage site. Under the measure, commercial operations could take place ranging from 50 to 200 nautical miles offshore, corresponding to 93 to 185 kilometers, while an inner 50-nautical-mile zone would stay protected for wildlife and habitat preservation.

Federal regulators stated that the revision aligns with directives from the Trump administration to expand harvest activities across Pacific waters, including an executive proclamation issued in April. The agency argued the move encourages the enduring viability of domestic fishing fleets, though officials simultaneously acknowledged that opening these grounds might produce only minor operational advantages. Members of the public can submit formal comments on the draft until December 9.

Conservationists and community leaders voiced swift objection, disputing the agency's assessment that risks to cultural heritage and vulnerable wildlife would be negligible. William Aila, a Native Hawaiian fisherman and former regional resource official, highlighted that these remote waters offer an essential sanctuary where endangered creatures feed, reproduce, and rebuild their populations. He expressed hope that community opposition would help safeguard the marine haven for upcoming generations.

According to the Pacific Islands Heritage Coalition, the sanctuary safeguards coral structures dating back 5,000 years along with 165 documented underwater peaks recognized as vital biological hotspots. The expanse provides vital territory for at-risk fauna including whales, sea turtles, rays, sharks, and various seabirds.

Legal challenges are already looming over the proposal. In April 2025, environmental organizations represented by Earthjustice successfully halted a similar attempt by filing a federal lawsuit. Following the latest draft, Earthjustice attorney David Henkin stated that the legal group is ready to return to court to challenge the government and defend the protected oceanic ecosystem.